There’s no place a Reform Jew would rather be on the second night of Passover than in a Catholic church, right?
Well, that’s where I was. Sitting on the aisle, in the second pew, all the way up at the front. Where everyone could see me standing alone when the rest of my row went up to the altar to receive communion.
You see, my son was confirmed this past Saturday night, the night before Easter, during the holy, and lengthy, Vigil Mass.
And I had to be there. I wanted to be there.
As he stood up in front of the altar, with his paternal grandmother standing behind him as his sponsor, I couldn’t help but be proud of him. For his commitment and his poise. For the young man he is.
And I was happy that I could be there, at 9:00 on a Saturday night, sitting next to my daughter and in the same pew as my ex-husband, his girlfriend and his girlfriend’s daughter.
Honestly.
My divorced family dynamic has the added twist of trying to include two different religions. (You can get the back-story in my previous post Guilty Gefilte.)
My first husband and I agreed to raise our kids primarily Catholic. He was a practicing Catholic and I was a non-practicing Jew. And what was important to me was that my children grew up learning about their Jewish heritage and celebrating the Jewish holidays in the same way that I had grown up celebrating them.
And once I had made the decision, once we had made the decision, I felt fine with it. Really fine with it. I had not been active in my faith since I graduated from high school. I went to a Jewish sleep away camp. I was bat mizvahed. But my formal education stopped when the confirmation classes interfered with my softball practices. And I really loved softball.
So when my first husband and I divorced, after almost eight years of marriage and with two previously-baptized children, I stood by my decision to have them raised Catholic. And promised to do my part to support them. And my ex-husband.
And I have.
So that’s how I ended up in a church on the second night of Passover. And even though I was sad that I didn’t get to go to my family seder this year, I did get to be a part of my son’s confirmation.
Looking across the church that night, at my son sitting next to his grandmother, I could see that he looked a little nervous. That he looked a bit like David Byrne in his arms-too-long dress shirt and in his new blazer that didn’t fit him quite right.
At that moment, he looked over at me. And gave me his smile. The smile that only his mother knows the meaning of. And I knew I was in the right place.
Sometimes you have to do things that aren’t your first choice, like sit in the second pew for the duration of a two-hour Mass on a Saturday night, feeling slightly out of place. But the decision to sit there is an easy one, one that you’ve made through a series of steps over a number of years.
And you are who you are.
I am the mother of two children. I am divorced from their father. They are being raised Catholic. And they celebrate their Jewish heritage.
And I’m okay with that. Because it’s my imperfect life.








12 comments
sheri says:
Apr 10, 2012
It continues to astound me, how much we have in common. My ex is Catholic and I am Jewish – however we decided to raise my 2 kids with him “neutral” – no bris, no confirmation, etc. In a very selfish way I am grateful for that as I think it would have been really challenging for me to sit, as the “Jew in the pew”. Your grace in handling this is to be admired, truly.
Jen @ Lifes Dewlaps says:
Apr 10, 2012
The shared experiences are pretty amazing. And having gotten to know you over the last few months, I know that you would be able to do it too. All for our kids, right? Thanks, Sheri!
ML@My3LittleBirds says:
Apr 10, 2012
Although my husband and I are raising our children in a shared faith, I can related to the emotions in your writing. As parents we all have to deal with the tension that exists between our personal expectations and desires and our partner’s.
Really nice post.
Jen @ Lifes Dewlaps says:
Apr 10, 2012
Thanks ML. I like the way that you put that… “the tension that exists between our personal expectations and desires and our partner’s” Definitely a universal theme.
Leslie says:
Apr 10, 2012
I love hearing your perspective on this. As the Catholic in my marriage (originally–my husband eventually converted from Protestantism on his own), I was the one who insisted our children would be raised Catholic. I have always wondered what it would be like to be on the other side of that equation. I think your children are exceptionally lucky to be raised without conflict on this issue but while still getting to learn about and celebrate the heritage they share with you.
Jen @ Lifes Dewlaps says:
Apr 10, 2012
Thanks Leslie. Honestly, it gets easier over time. Especially when you keep the perspective that it’s all about the kids.
Heather@ That Uncomfortable Itch says:
Apr 10, 2012
It’s so lovely that you have a comfortable balance. Hats off to you and your family for sharing and respecting diversity.
In our divorce, I was the Catholic and he the very non-practicing Mormon. He’s always been tolerant and hands off with the Catholicism and it helps so much, though that’s not to say he doesn’t roll his eyes at our youngest’s uniform and weekly Mass on Thursday’s.
Jen @ Lifes Dewlaps says:
Apr 10, 2012
Thanks Heather. But that’s not to say that there aren’t times that I want to roll my eyes too! It can be a tough situation. And it helps that my kids’ father is very respectful of Judaism as well.
Elena @CiaoMom says:
Apr 10, 2012
As a divorced mom whose ex-husband (non practicing episcopalian) agreed to raise our daughter Jewish-I get this. On so many levels. Coming together–even after a marriage that does not stay together, around a topic because and FOR our kids is crucial.
Jen @ Lifes Dewlaps says:
Apr 11, 2012
I agree. Being able to come together is ideal but I think that the majority of divorced couples are not able to do this. I feel lucky that we can. And it is so much better for the kids. Though it is not always easy to do!
Bill K. says:
Apr 13, 2012
As a non-practicing Jew myself, I’m a little offended by your lack of commitment to true non-practicing Judaism. You should be raising your children in the proud traditions of non-practicing Judaism. Eating bacon, not fasting when one is supposed to fast, being bar-mitsva’ed only for the loot, misspelling “bar-mitsva,” etc. Allowing your son to be confirmed and then sitting in church while it’s actually happening? Church?! Really? Why that’s just… actually, I guess that’s completely appropriate for a non-practicing Jew. Never mind.
Jen @ Lifes Dewlaps says:
Apr 13, 2012
But I do eat bacon. And so do they. And prosciutto, too.